Fluke Comparison of Emerson TREX-475 Alternatives

TREX

Emerson moved away from a traditional handheld and launched their tablet-based TREX series to replace the 475 and older handhelds like the 375 and 275. The TREX series does everything that the 475 did and has additional capabilities, for example in addition to Bluetooth, it adds Wifi and USB. Optionally, Loop Diagnostics (order code L) can be chosen to include a 24 VDC power supply to power transmitters. It also includes the ValveLink Mobile app to perform valve diagnostics.


Fluke

Fluke 754 is a fully documenting process calibrator in the price range of the TREX. It has limited HART communications for HART calibration menus in the HART device. While not fully HART capable, it can access the device calibration menus. The big bonus is its multifunction capabilities. Measure and source, volts, mA, RTD and thermocouple temperature, frequency, pulses. Optional pressure modules are available for measuring pressure to calibrate pressure transmitters.

Fluke 154 is a tablet-based HART unit with full HART DD’s (device description). Quarterly free updates are available for DD’s. See more about DD’s in the Meriam discussion.

Fluke offers a cost saving 754/154 bundle

NOTE: These models are HART only and not available as I.S. (intrinsically safe)


Druck

Druck DPI 620G Genii series is a great value for full HART and/or Foundation Fieldbus capability plus it is a fully documenting multifunction calibrator functions. It has a smartphone-like touchscreen interface. There are several versions available. Select from models with full HART and Foundation Fieldbus (FF) to only HART or Lite version without HART or FF. They also have Profibus version available. Some Genii models are available with I.S. (intrinsically safe) approvals. The HART and Foundation Fieldbus can be updated free. HART/Fieldbus/Profibus if selected are complete, no limitations of just calibration menus like some other manufacturers. See more about DD’s in the Meriam discussion. Measure and source, volts, mA, RTD and thermocouple temperature, frequency, pulses. Optional pressure modules are available for measuring pressure to calibrate pressure transmitters.


Druck DPI 620 Genii - Overview of HART Capabilities

This video provides a brief overview of the process for using a Druck DPI 620 Genii Multifunction Calibrator to calibrate a HART device. In the video example, we use a temperature transmitter but this process is applicable to other HART instruments as well. Presented by Steve Sajben, Product Specialist with Druck Inc.


Additel

Additel 223A is a fully documenting process calibrator that will measure and source mA, millivolts, volts, ohms, frequency, pulses, RTDs and thermocouples. Optional pressure modules are available for measuring pressure to calibrate pressure transmitters. It has a smartphone-like menu and a keypad. HART capabilities are limited to calibration related menus of the field instrument. NOTE: This unit does not include nor offer optionally Foundation Fieldbus communications or I.S. (intrinsically safe).


MERIAM

Meriam 5150 and 5150X (Z5150-MER and Z5150-MERX) have modernized the concept of a HART Communicator and made it more affordable.  NOTE: The Meriam unit does not include nor offer optionally Foundation Fieldbus communications.

HART field instruments have default parameters that can be accessed from a HART Communicator for setting ranges, for example, but are limited. Each instrument manufacturer has custom HART parameters that can only be accessed after publishing of the appropriate Device Driver (DD) and have it loaded into the HART Communicator. Of course, a new HART Communicator includes many instrument DD's, but in time they become outdated as new instrument models are released. Emerson charges several hundred dollars for their subscription. Meanwhile, Meriam offers free downloadable updates.

The Emerson 475/TREX cannot accept the Device Drivers directly. Emerson has to convert them, then the published conversion file is released to subscribers for download. However, there is a time lag of weeks or months. The Meriam 5150 and 5150X accepts the DDs directly. They can be obtained from Meriam or from the field instrument manufacturer.

Comparing the hardware, Meriam's QWERTY keyboard is a noticeable difference. Having a full keyboard makes it easier to enter tag names and other data directly. The Meriam unit also has a larger display and memory.

Meriam also made ordering easier with just two models: 5150, the base model, and 5150X which is intrinsically safe and is designed for hazardous areas.


Comparison of Trex-475 Alternatives - non intrinsically safe (I.S.) models

  Emerson Fluke Druck Additel Meriam
Model TREXLHPNAWS3S TREXLFPNAWS3S 754 154 DPI 620G DPI 620G-FF DPI 602G-PB ADT223A MFC 5150
Key Notes HART HART, FF HART HART HART HART, FF HART, Profibus HART HART
Measures DC voltage and mA Y Y Y N Y Y Y Y N
Powers the loop Y Y Y N Y Y Y Y N
Full HART Communications Y Y N N Y Y Y N Y
HART Communications for Calibration Menus Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Foundation Fieldbus Communications N Y N N N Y N N N
Profibus Communications N N N N N N Y N N
Free lifetime upgrades for device descriptions (DD) N N Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Emerson free upgrade number of years 3 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
Intrinsically Safe N N N N N N N N N
Documenting Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y N
Temperature Calibrator N N Y N Y Y Y Y N
Pressure Calibrator with optional modules N N Y N Y Y Y Y N
Frequency/Pulse Calibrator N N Y N Y Y Y Y N
mA Calibrator N N Y N Y Y Y Y N
Volts DC Calibrator N N Y N Y Y Y Y N


Comparison of Trex-475 Alternatives - intrinsically safe (I.S.) models

  Emerson Druck Meriam
Model TREXLHPKLWS3S TREXLFPKLWS3S DPI620G-IS DPI620G-IS-FF DPI620G-IS-PB MFC 5150X
Key Notes HART, I.S. HART, FF, I.S. HART, I.S. HART, FF, I.S. HART,Profibus, I.S. HART, I.S.
Measures DC voltage and mA Y Y Y Y Y N
Powers the loop Y Y Y Y Y N
Full HART Communications Y Y Y Y Y Y
HART Communications for Calibration Menus Y Y Y Y Y Y
Foundation Fieldbus Communications N Y N Y N N
Profibus Communications N N N N Y N
Free lifetime upgrades for device descriptions (DD) N N Y Y Y Y
Emerson free upgrade number of years 3 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A
Intrinsically Safe Y Y Y Y Y Y
Documenting Y Y Y Y Y N
Temperature Calibrator N N Y Y Y N
Pressure Calibrator with optional modules N N Y Y Y N
Frequency/Pulse Calibrator N N Y Y Y N
mA Calibrator N N Y Y Y N
Volts DC Calibrator N N Y Y Y N
ModelEmerson TREXLHPKLWS3SEmerson TREXLFPNAWS3SEmerson TREXLHPNAWS3SEmerson TREXLFPKLWS3S
ProductTREX - Device Communicator Plus module; HART application; ATEX, CSA (US/Canada) and...TREX - Device Communicator Plus module; HART/FOUNDATION application; without...TREX - Device Communicator Plus module; HART application; without ATEX/CSA;IECEx...TREX - Device Communicator Plus module; HART/FOUNDATION application; ATEX, CSA...
Rating(0)(0)(0)(0)
Price
In Stock

Process / Calibration/Multifunction Calibrators

TypeHand HeldHand HeldHand HeldHand Held
Measure VoltageYesYesYesYes
Simulate Loop VoltageYesNoNoNo
Source/Simulate DC CurrentYesYesYesYes
Measure DC CurrentYesYesYesYes
Hart CompatibleYesYesYesYes
FieldBus CompatibleNoNoNoYes
BacklightedYesYesYesYes
Intrinsically Safe(Calibrators)YesNoNoYes

Test Equipment General Attributes

Warranty1 YEARS1 YEARS1 YEARS1 YEARS
IP RatingIP54IP54IP54
X